← Back Published on

What to Order at Green Street Smoked Meats When You Want the Best Bites First

Some restaurants win you over before the food arrives. Green Street Smoked Meats begins with a brick-paved West Loop alley that looks as if it knows you are about to take pictures.

When I visited during the holiday season, greenery and warm lights stretched overhead between the brick buildings. The entrance felt tucked away, a little dramatic and much more charming than I expected from a barbecue restaurant. Inside, the mood shifted into rustic warehouse territory: exposed wood, metal, communal seating, a central bar and enough people circling for a table that finding a seat briefly felt like a game of duck, duck, goose.

I will admit something that makes the rest of this review more interesting: I arrived with low expectations.

I was very wrong.

Green Street serves Central Texas-inspired barbecue by the half pound in a counter-service setting. Our table did not approach this meal cautiously. We ordered brisket, pastrami, ribs, smoked cheddar-jalapeño sausage, the Chicago Twinky and pickled vegetables. It was enough food to turn the tray into a small landscape.

If you are visiting for the first time, however, you do not need to order everything. Here is exactly where I would start.

The short answer: order these first

  1. Pastrami
  2. Brisket
  3. Chicago Twinky
  4. Ribs
  5. Pickled vegetables to break up all that glorious richness

The smoked cheddar-jalapeño sausage was fine, but it would not make my essential first-timer order. There are only so many bites a person can manage, and Green Street has better ways to use them.

Brisket and smoked meats with bread and pickled vegetables at Green Street Smoked Meats

A generous tray with the brisket and sides. Photo by Jazzmine E. Razaa.

The pastrami was the surprise star

The pastrami was the bite I kept returning to. It was juicy, deeply seasoned and flavorful enough that it did not need mustard or any other rescue mission. The exterior carried the seasoning beautifully, while the meat stayed moist and tender.

Pastrami can sometimes become more about salt than the actual meat. This did not. It tasted rich, smoky and deliberate.

If you are splitting a tray with someone who claims they do not need much pastrami, let them place their own order. Protect your portion.

The brisket lived up to the reputation

The brisket was the other star: smoky, moist and especially satisfying with the sweeter barbecue sauce. The bark brought the deeper flavor, while the inside stayed tender and juicy.

This is the item most people expect to order at a barbecue restaurant, and Green Street gives you a reason to follow the crowd for once. If you can only choose two meats, make them the brisket and pastrami.

The Chicago Twinky is not a gimmick

The Chicago Twinky sounds like the sort of menu item invented to become a social-media dare. It is a bacon-wrapped jalapeño filled with brisket, cream cheese and giardiniera, and it is genuinely delicious.

It delivered heat, smoke, creaminess and a little sweetness in the same bite. The giardiniera gave it the unmistakably Chicago touch, while the brisket kept it from becoming just another stuffed pepper.

Menu availability can change, but if the Chicago Twinky is offered when you visit, add one to the tray. This is the fun order that earns its place next to the serious barbecue.

A shared barbecue tray at Green Street Smoked Meats

The shared tray at the table. Photo by Jazzmine E. Razaa.

What I would not prioritize next time

The smoked cheddar-jalapeño sausage was decent, but it was the least memorable part of our order. It had the richness you expect from sausage and a pleasant flavor, but when it sat beside the brisket and pastrami, it simply could not compete.

That does not make it bad. It makes it the item I would sacrifice when stomach space becomes valuable, which happens quickly here.

The atmosphere is part of the experience

Green Street does not feel polished in the white-tablecloth sense, and that is exactly why the space works. It is lively, industrial and communal. The alley creates a memorable arrival, while the warehouse-style dining room feels casual enough for messy fingers and a tray full of meat.

Seating can be competitive when the restaurant is busy. Come prepared to order at the counter, look for space and embrace the possibility of sharing a table. This is not the place for an intimate whispered conversation. It is a place to lean over a tray and debate whether the next bite should be brisket or pastrami.

The correct answer is both.

Is Green Street Smoked Meats worth visiting?

Yes, especially if you want a lively West Loop meal that feels distinctly Chicago without defaulting to deep-dish pizza.

I went in expecting a cute alley and an acceptable dinner. I left thinking about the pastrami, the brisket and how incorrect my first impression had been. The food was generous, the staff was friendly and the strongest dishes delivered the kind of flavor that makes planning a return visit feel completely reasonable.

For a first visit, keep the order focused. Start with brisket and pastrami, add a Chicago Twinky if it is available, bring someone willing to share and do not waste your appetite pretending you only want a light bite.

Smoked salmon served with lemon and crackers at Green Street Smoked Meats

Smoked salmon served with lemon, sauce and crackers. Photo by Jazzmine E. Razaa.

Before you go

Green Street Smoked Meats
112 N. Green Street, Chicago, Illinois 60607
West Loop

Green Street’s menu, hours and prices can change. Check the restaurant’s current website before visiting.

Planning a food-focused Chicago weekend? Download Jazzmine’s free Chicago Bite List for neighborhood strategy, honest bookmarks and the meals worth building a day around.